Advance Comment
Writing Peace


"In Writing Peace, Melanie Springer Mock makes a valuable and unique contribution to the literature on conscientious objection in America. She reveals the vivid drama of conscientious objection in the lives of four men who were conscripted during World War I into military cantonments and lived out their convictions as pacifists among soldiers waiting to be sent overseas. Their diaries published in this volume not only bring us into contact with their hearts and minds but also reveal their individual strategies for maintaining a sense of self and belief in a confining and often abusive context. Mock's thoughtful, informed commentary teaches us how to read these diaries for their deeper cultural, historical, and literary significance and skillfully places them in the context of Great War literature and the history of conscientious objection in America. This is a timely book as once more our nation deploys rhetoric in preparation for a ‘holy war’ and lacks clear provisons for conscientious objectors in its draft registration policies."
—Ann Hostetler, Associate Professor of English, Goshen College

"With almost cinematic drama and scope, Melanie Springer Mock explores in Writing Peace: The Unheard Voices of Great War Mennonite Objectors the struggles of young conscientious objectors to protect their honor—and yet retain their belief in country—during America’s first world war. From the beginning of their journey, these men of deep faith, conscripted to fight for their homeland, faced a hard decision—journey to France and the battle, or endure confinement in American military barracks for their refusal to bear arms. Mock brings us every colorful moment of this unique American story by establishing and presenting—for the first time—clear and reliable texts of each of four representative diarists whose personal nightmares she unflinchingly and sensitively recounts."

"Using the most scrupulous and contemporary standards for textual editing, Mock edits the diaries and then details in an engaging and lively introduction the American cultural climate during the years of the Great War that led to the shunning of conscientious objectors. She identifies the particular problems the Mennonites faced and draws a series of conclusions that reveal the all-too-alarming reactions of the American public—then, and perhaps now—to a policy of non-violence."

"The most impressive feature of Writing Peace is its readability. Beautifully penned, Melanie Springer Mock’s first book creates a sensitive and intriguing story of a little known event in American history. Free of jargon and trenchant academic prose, Writing Peace captures the triumph and tragedy of a people that represents a saga in American history."
—Jeffrey Walker, Department of English, Oklahoma State University

Writing Peace provides new documentation of the experiences of American Conscience Objectors to World War I, those 4,000 heroes who were among the founders of militant nonviolence in our country. The diaries here of four Mennonite draftees reveal the inner experience and character of men little-known to the wider public, even though roughly half of all WWI CO's were Mennonite. Melanie Springer Mock's sensitive, restrained editing brings them to life, proving that the writers were not "bovine-faced" religious nuts, as they were judged at the time. Her three introductory chapters further integrate them into our literary, political, and military history by showing the cultural kinships of CO's and soldiers and the isolation of both from the civilian world. She also shows how these wartime trials later helped make the peace churches like the Mennonites more politically engaged. Combatants, as she says, bear the weapons of war but not the total cost. The nonviolent resistors to the Great War paid too—but also had profound historical effect."
—Robert F. Sayre, Professor Emeritus, University of Iowa, and editor of American Lives

"The war to make the world safe for democracy, contrary to its progressive goals, created the conditions for more war. Tragically, the "profiling" of German-speaking pacifists in World War I may now be compared with what is happening to Arabic-speaking Muslims in America, even as the nation may also again be giving heightened emphasis to a view of itself as ‘an instrument in the hand of God.’ Writing Peace represents a relevant resource for understanding the experience of outsiders in wartime in the twenty-first century."
—James C. Juhnke, Professor of History (retired), Bethel College; and co-author with Carol Hunter), The Missing Peace: The Search for Nonviolent Alternatives in United States History


Writing Peace orders:


 
        Click here to explore joining InnerCircle readers club and receiving occasional updates and special discounts.  
           
           
           

Copyright © 2003 by Cascadia Publishing House
04/15/03